India

Former Indian officials, activists serve impeachment notice on CEC Gyanesh Kumar

Delegation says poll chief violated law, undermined electoral integrity

New Delhi : Concerns over the integrity of India’s electoral process, have intensified after a group of former Indian senior bureaucrats, diplomats and civil society members issued a “Chargesheet and Notice of Impeachment” against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, demanding his immediate resignation or removal over what they described a “sustained pattern of willful disregard of law and constitutional duty.”

According to Kashmir Media Service, the notice was issued by a delegation that included former Delhi Lieutenant Governor Najeeb Jung, former Indian Home Secretary G K Pillai, former Indian Secretary Amitabha Pandey, former ambassador shok Sharma and former Special Director Intelligence Bureau Yashovardhan Azad. It was also endorsed by activists and public figures, including Yogendra Yadav, Anjali Bhardwaj, Aishe Ghosh, and Amrita Johri, among others.

The delegation had planned to submit the notice to the Election Commission of India (ECI) at its headquarters in New Delhi on Monday but said it was prevented from doing so as routes leading to the office were barricaded. The members subsequently held a press conference at the Press Club of India to announce the notice and outline their charges against the CEC.

The delegation said that the charges did not concern ordinary errors of judgment, incompetence or policy failures, but a “sustained pattern of willful disregard of law and constitutional duty, abuse of authority and conduct destructive of the integrity of India’s electoral democracy.”

The six charges outlined in the notice include:

Undermining the collective functioning of the ECI: The notice alleged that Kumar repeatedly exercised powers without placing matters before the full Commission for proper consideration. It cited the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) as a major decision undertaken without adequate discussion or consultation. The document also referred to reported objections by two Election Commissioners over decisions taken without their knowledge and meetings held without proper agendas and minutes. It argued that decisions taken in the name of the Commission without being placed before it amounted to a “fundamental abuse of constitutional authority.”

Unauthorised changes to Form 6: The delegation alleged that Kumar authorized a modified Form 6 for electoral-roll revision despite internal objections that the alteration was “unauthorised and illegal.” The notice said, “You are guilty for forcing crores of citizens to make a false declaration to correct an error for which the electoral authorities themselves were responsible.”

Unlawful centralisation and manipulation of electoral-roll administration: The notice alleged that Kumar authorised the deployment of ECINET in a manner that undermined or displaced the statutory role of Electoral Registration Officers, who are the authorities legally entrusted with additions, deletions and corrections in electoral rolls.

It said that the system was introduced despite objections concerning its legality and functioning, and that the subsequent decision to constitute an expert committee to verify whether ECINET complied with the governing Acts and Rules amounted to an “extraordinary admission” that a system already used to delete crores of names from electoral rolls had not been adequately established as legally compliant.

The delegation said that Kumar had therefore “designed or overseen technological mechanisms to override statutory authority, despite being put on notice.”

Mass disenfranchisement through SIR: One of the most severe allegations concerned the SIR exercise, which the delegation described as an “unprecedented mass disenfranchisement.” The document said that by shifting the onus of voter registration onto citizens and reversing the presumption of citizenship, the process “subjected millions of citizens to burdens that foreseeably resulted in wrongful exclusion.”

The notice claimed that 13.3 crore names had been deleted from the pre-SIR electoral rolls, warning that the gap between adult population and the electorate could reach “15 crores or more, suggesting largest ever ‘missing voters’ in human history.”

It further alleged that the deletions “disproportionately affected vulnerable citizens, especially the women, the poor, migrants, minorities and the elderly.” The delegation held the CEC guilty of “reckless disregard of the foundational principle of universal adult franchise.”

Political partisanship: The delegation accused Kumar of conduct that, in its view, created a “reasonable and substantial apprehension of political partisanship, thereby violating the constitutional expectation that the Election Commission must function without fear or favour.”

“You can no longer be a referee in a game where you are widely perceived to be aligned with a player,” the notice said.

Breach of statutory duty: The sixth charge cited Section 32(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, which, it said, “makes it an offence for an election official, without reasonable cause, to commit an act or omission in breach of official duty in connection with the preparation or revision of electoral rolls. The unauthorised alteration of statutory forms, the circumvention of statutory Electoral Registration Officers, the use of dubious technological system, concealment of records, non-disclosure of relevant information and failure to rectify known violations together disclose a prima facie pattern of wilful breach of official duty.”

The notice concluded that the cumulative actions have resulted in “large-scale disenfranchisement, erosion of public confidence and the weakening of the Election Commission’s institutional independence.”

“We, the People of India, therefore serve this Notice of Impeachment upon you,” the document stated, adding that the acts outlined in the notice constituted “proved misbehavior” under Article 324(5) of the Constitution and demanding Kumar’s removal as Chief Election Commissioner.

Read also

Back to top button