Modi’s Growing Crisis of Credibility (Part II)
Unemployment, corporate concentration, mounting protests and the policing of dissent are raising difficult questions about the sustainability of Narendra Modi’s political model.
Humayun Aziz Sandeela
The political and institutional pressures confronting Narendra Modi are only part of the story. The other part concerns the promises that helped sustain his popularity: jobs for young Indians, rising prosperity, national strength and decisive governance. When these promises collide with economic insecurity, questions about corporate influence and growing public discontent, the consequences can extend beyond individual policies to the credibility of the government itself.
The voter-roll controversy has brought these pressures together, turning a dispute over electoral procedures into a wider argument about accountability, civil liberties and the limits of political power. Yet the durability of Modi’s political model will also depend on whether the government can persuade ordinary citizens that economic growth is improving their lives and that powerful interests are subject to the same rules as everyone else.
The economic promise meets the employment test
Modi’s political appeal has depended heavily on the promise that strong leadership and economic growth would deliver jobs, prosperity and greater opportunities for young Indians. But headline growth figures cannot answer the question of whether sufficient secure and productive employment is available to the millions entering the labour market.
World Bank data, drawing on International Labour Organization estimates, put India’s modelled youth unemployment rate for people aged 15 to 24 at approximately 16 per cent in 2025. The national estimate for the same age group was higher, at 17.7 per cent. These are annual figures and should not be mistaken for a direct measure of conditions in October 2026, but they underline the employment challenge facing the country.
For young people, economic performance is not measured by the size of the national economy or the number of infrastructure projects announced. It is measured by whether they can find reliable work, earn enough to support a household, obtain an education that leads somewhere and build a future without depending on family connections or political patronage.
A country can record substantial economic growth while many citizens remain frustrated by precarious employment, insecure earnings and intense competition for limited opportunities. The central question is not whether India has developed economically, but whether the benefits are reaching people in ways they can feel in their daily lives.
This is where economic grievances can intersect with political discontent. Young people who believe that the system offers them little prospect of advancement may become more receptive to movements challenging established institutions. They may also turn against a governing party that has presented itself as the guarantor of their future.
The BJP cannot assume that nationalist appeals will indefinitely compensate for unfulfilled economic expectations. A government that promises transformation must demonstrate that growth translates into productive employment, rising living standards and meaningful opportunities across social and regional divides. Otherwise, the gap between the promise and the lived experience of citizens risks becoming a source of political vulnerability.
Crony capitalism and the question of who holds power
The relationship between political authority and concentrated private wealth is another vulnerability in the BJP’s governing model. Large corporations are essential to investment, infrastructure, employment and technological development. Their size or commercial success is not, by itself, evidence of wrongdoing. The concern arises when the public begins to suspect that regulatory decisions, market access or government policy favour powerful business interests at the expense of fair competition.
Under Modi, the spectacular rise of corporate groups such as Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance Industries and Gautam Adani’s conglomerate has fuelled persistent allegations of crony capitalism. Critics have questioned whether political access and corporate influence have become too closely intertwined. The companies concerned have denied wrongdoing where allegations have been made, and any assessment must distinguish documented findings from accusations and political interpretations.
The controversy surrounding Adani intensified after Hindenburg Research published allegations of stock manipulation and improper use of offshore entities in January 2023. Adani Group rejected the allegations. The ensuing market turmoil damaged the group’s share prices and led it to abandon a planned $2.5 billion share sale, bringing international scrutiny to questions of corporate governance and financial oversight. The episode did not establish that the Indian government had improperly favoured the group, but it intensified debate about regulatory independence and the accountability of politically influential business interests.
The relationship between political authority and private wealth returned to international attention in October 2026 during the dispute over SpaceX’s Starlink satellite internet service and its entry into India. The Financial Times reported in October 2026 that Elon Musk publicly challenged Ambani over delays affecting Starlink’s market entry and sarcastically referred to the Reliance chairman as “Prime Minister Ambani”. The Indian government denied favouring one applicant, stating that Starlink, Reliance Jio and OneWeb were awaiting final security clearance.
The significance of the dispute lies not in Musk’s rhetoric alone, but in the questions it raises about competition and regulatory impartiality. If companies competing in the same market believe that access depends on political influence rather than transparent rules, confidence in the business environment can suffer. The government has a responsibility to ensure that licensing, spectrum policy and security clearances are administered fairly and consistently.
The broader question concerns the credibility of Modi’s economic model. If the government promises a competitive, world-class economy, it must ensure that smaller businesses and new entrants have a fair opportunity to compete with established corporate giants. Transparent regulation, equal treatment and public accountability are essential not only for entrepreneurs but also for the credibility of the state.
When citizens believe that influential corporations enjoy preferential access while ordinary people struggle with unemployment and economic insecurity, the government risks losing the argument that its model serves the national interest. The damage extends beyond individual companies: it can undermine investor confidence, invite international scrutiny and deepen the perception that economic success is concentrated in the hands of a favoured few.
The streets are sending a warning
Public protests are not, by themselves, proof that a government is losing control or that an electoral defeat is imminent. Democracies routinely experience demonstrations over economic conditions, public services, political decisions and civil liberties. Their significance depends on their scale, composition, demands and the government’s response.
Nevertheless, the scale of mobilisation can offer an important indication of public grievances. Reporting by Business Standard on October 11, 2026, citing data from the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED), said India recorded 20,606 demonstrations in 2025 and 18,074 through September 2026. The figures suggest that street mobilisation remains a significant feature of India’s political and social landscape. The growing frequency of protests may signal mounting public discontent that threatens to erode Modi’s popularity, particularly among young people frustrated by unemployment, electoral controversies and unfulfilled promises. These demonstrations not only prove a nationwide decline in his support, but also expose vulnerabilities that the BJP can no longer afford to ignore.
The latest voter-roll protests have been particularly consequential because they concern the right to participate in elections. Reuters reported on October 13 that opposition parties and youth-led activists were challenging the removal of approximately 130 million names from electoral rolls under the SIR exercise. The Election Commission says the revision is intended to remove invalid entries, while critics argue that eligible voters risk being excluded.
For the protesters, the controversy is about more than an administrative exercise. It is about whether institutions responsible for safeguarding the vote can command public confidence and whether citizens can challenge decisions affecting their democratic rights without being treated as a threat to public order.
The response of the authorities therefore matters as much as the original controversy. When peaceful mobilisation is met with sweeping restrictions, mass detentions or allegations of excessive force, a dispute that might have been addressed through explanation and independent review can become a broader confrontation over civil liberties.
The government has a legitimate responsibility to maintain public order and respond to violence. But that responsibility does not remove the need to distinguish peaceful demonstrators from those committing offences, or to ensure that any use of force is necessary, proportionate and accountable. A state that responds to every challenge primarily through security measures risks deepening the grievances that brought people into the streets in the first place.
When dissent is met with force, democracy pays the price
A government’s commitment to democracy is tested not when citizens applaud it, but when they challenge it. The real measure of Modi’s government is not how efficiently it can clear streets, detain demonstrators or impose restrictions, but whether it can tolerate public anger without treating dissent as a threat to be crushed.
The voter-roll protests have brought this question into sharp focus. The police response in New Delhi on October 10, 2026, prompted further scrutiny after large numbers of demonstrators were detained. The Indian Express reported that approximately 6,000 people were detained during the protests, while other reports described extensive restrictions and a major security deployment.
The concern becomes more serious when the latest crackdown is viewed alongside previous confrontations between protesters and the authorities. In July 2026, during a Cockroach Janta Party-led march towards Parliament over alleged examination irregularities, security personnel used crowd-control munitions, including plastic pellets. The Tribune reported on July 28 that an official police record documented the firing of two rounds containing plastic pellets during the July 20 demonstration.
Amnesty International subsequently reported that its investigation had documented the use of pellet-firing shotguns, tear-gas launchers, grenades, batons and electric-shock devices against protesters between July 20 and 24. The organisation raised concerns about excessive force and the lack of accountability. Delhi Police disputed allegations of unlawful or disproportionate force. These competing claims make an independent and credible examination of the incidents essential.
The use of pellet-firing weapons carries an especially disturbing resonance in Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir, where such weapons have caused severe eye injuries and permanent blindness among protesters. Their reported use in Delhi renewed concerns about the risks of deploying weapons capable of inflicting devastating injuries in crowd-control situations.
The issue is not whether authorities have a duty to maintain order. They do. It is whether the methods they choose are necessary, proportionate and subject to meaningful accountability. When potentially devastating weapons are used against demonstrators, assurances that the situation was handled professionally cannot substitute for independent scrutiny.
The farmers’ agitation of 2020–21 offers another reminder of how quickly a dispute over government policy can become a confrontation over the right to protest. Farmers opposing the Modi government’s agricultural reforms camped for months on the outskirts of Delhi. On January 26, 2021, sections of a tractor parade departed from agreed routes, broke through barricades and entered central Delhi. Clashes resulted in one death and hundreds of injuries, including injuries to police officers. Reuters documented how the confrontation escalated from a major protest into violent clashes.
The violence committed by some demonstrators was real and cannot be excused. But neither can it erase the larger lesson: when governments and protesters become locked in confrontation, the space for negotiation narrows, public trust deteriorates and the original grievances risk being overshadowed by the battle over law and order.
The treatment of journalists during the latest voter-roll demonstrations has added another troubling dimension. The Committee to Protect Journalists reported on October 12 that at least 37 journalists were temporarily detained while covering protests in New Delhi, Ahmedabad and Pune on October 10 and 11. Several journalists said they were assaulted, obstructed or prevented from carrying out their work. The organisation also reported that police seized phones and that at least one journalist was pressured to delete footage.
Police said some protesters had disguised themselves as journalists, a claim that warrants examination where specific evidence exists. But it cannot justify treating all reporters at a demonstration as suspect. Journalists are not merely spectators at a protest; they are the public’s eyes and ears. When reporters are dragged away, their equipment is threatened or their ability to document police conduct is obstructed, citizens lose an essential means of determining what actually happened.
This is where Modi’s government faces a consequential test. It cannot answer every challenge to its authority with barricades, mass detentions and restrictions, then expect public confidence to remain untouched. Nor can it invoke public order as a blanket justification for actions that demand independent examination. Peaceful demonstrators must be protected, violence must be addressed lawfully, journalists must be allowed to report freely, and credible allegations of police misconduct must be investigated without political interference.
A government may disperse a crowd, but it cannot arrest a grievance out of existence. If citizens fear that questioning electoral procedures will bring detention, that documenting a protest may invite assault, or that allegations of excessive force will go unanswered, the damage extends far beyond one demonstration. It strikes at the confidence on which democratic institutions depend.
Is this the beginning of Modi’s downfall?
Political decline rarely announces itself with a single electoral defeat. It begins when the promises that once propelled a leader to power collide with the realities citizens experience every day; when economic grievances accumulate, institutions face growing scrutiny, social divisions widen and the government increasingly appears more concerned with controlling dissent than addressing public discontent.
Modi remains a powerful political figure, and the BJP retains substantial organisational strength. But neither fact guarantees enduring dominance. The warning signs are becoming harder to dismiss: controversies over voter-roll revisions have raised questions about electoral transparency; the policing of protests has intensified concerns about civil liberties; scrutiny of corporate concentration has revived allegations of crony capitalism; and persistent employment challenges and social polarisation have exposed the limits of the promise that Modi’s leadership would deliver prosperity, stability and national unity.
What makes these pressures particularly consequential is their cumulative effect. The voter-roll controversy strikes at the foundation of democratic representation. Concerns raised by Freedom House and other research organisations add to questions about institutional independence and civil liberties. The continuing conflict in Manipur, the unresolved political questions surrounding occupied Kashmir and documented incidents of hate speech against minorities particularly Muslims and Christians expose the human and political costs of a national narrative that promises unity while struggling to reconcile deep social divisions. Meanwhile, youth unemployment threatens the credibility of the promise that economic growth will translate into secure livelihoods and opportunity.
The relationship between political authority and private wealth adds another layer of vulnerability. Controversies surrounding Adani, questions about the competitive environment facing businesses and the public dispute over Starlink’s entry into India have intensified scrutiny of regulatory impartiality and corporate influence. These developments pose a serious test of the economic and political model he has championed.
The more troubling possibility for Modi is that the methods used to preserve political dominance could accelerate its erosion. When protests are met with mass detentions, journalists report alleged mistreatment, critics question institutional impartiality and public grievances are increasingly framed as challenges to authority, the government risks alienating citizens whose confidence it needs. Coercion can disperse a demonstration, but it cannot resolve unemployment, restore faith in electoral procedures or bridge religious and ethnic divisions.
Nor can nationalist messaging permanently compensate for economic disappointment or institutional distrust. Political loyalty is not fixed, and a leader’s reputation for decisiveness can become a liability when citizens begin to see strength as an unwillingness to listen. The more the BJP relies on projecting invulnerability, the more damaging the gap between its claims and citizens’ lived experiences may become.
The opposition, however, cannot assume that Modi’s vulnerabilities will automatically translate into victory. Political dissatisfaction becomes an electoral threat only when it finds credible leadership, a persuasive programme and a coalition broad enough to turn disparate grievances into a common alternative. The BJP retains organisational advantages and an established political base. Whether its opponents can convert public discontent into a coherent political challenge remains an open question.
The first cracks in a political edifice do not mean that it is about to collapse. They mean that its strength can no longer be taken for granted.
The danger for Modi is that voter distrust, economic frustration, social polarisation and questions about the relationship between political power and corporate wealth may no longer be isolated problems. They may be converging into a wider crisis of credibility, challenging the claim that his political model offers India a stable, prosperous and inclusive future.
A government can command a parliamentary majority without enjoying unlimited public trust. It can disperse protesters without resolving their grievances, and it can project national strength while its claims of inclusive progress face mounting scrutiny. If Modi’s government fails to restore confidence in electoral institutions, demonstrate that the law applies equally to the powerful and the ordinary, create meaningful economic opportunities and protect the rights of those who challenge it, the accumulated damage could become far more consequential than any single protest or controversy.
The growing frequency of protests may signal mounting public discontent that threatens to erode Modi’s popularity, particularly among young people frustrated by unemployment, electoral controversies and unfulfilled promises. These demonstrations prove a nationwide decline in his support, and expose vulnerabilities that the BJP can no longer afford to ignore.









