Naravane’s remarks attempt to downplay Chinese incursion: Analysts
Locals contradict ex-army chief, say Indian villages now held by China
New Delhi: Defence analysts have termed former Indian Army Chief General Manoj M. Naravane’s statement describing India-China face-offs along Line of Actual Control as nothing new as an attempt to downplay Chinese incursion and a tacit approval to China’s advance in the name of lack of border demarcation. However, local population clearly says that their villages which were once under Indian control are now in control of Chinese army.
General Naravane, who was Army chief at time of Galwan clash in eastern Ladakh in June 2020 which left 20 Indian soldiers dead, made remarks after Indo-Tibetan Border Police Director General Shatrujeet Kapur explicitly admitted Indian forces’ incapability to confront Chinese forces along LAC in Arunachal Pradesh.
Speaking to The Tribune on sidelines of Kasauli Lit Fest, Naravane said, “You see, we have to understand that the boundary between India and the Tibet region has never been formally demarcated or formally acknowledged by either side. And therefore, there are differences in perception about where the boundary actually lies.”
“So whenever such patrolling takes place, there are occasions when patrols arrive simultaneously at a particular point, resulting in what is called a face-off. So these face-offs are nothing new. They have happened in past, and there are established protocols,” he added, saying “we should not read too much into it.
“His statement came after Congress sought explanation from Prime Minister Narendra Modi over ITBP DG’s video and Ministry of External Affairs said on October 23 that LAC was disturbed from time to time when PLA “deviates from established patrolling patterns.” However, ITBP deleted its Director General’s video from its official YouTube channel.
Analysts said remarks are aimed at covering up Modi government’s failure to protect territorial integrity despite most recent meeting between PM Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping on September 12 on sidelines of BRICS summit in New Delhi.
When asked about ITBP deleting video, Naravane said, “I’m now retired. It’s been four years since I retired. I have no idea what is happening on day-to-day basis in border area.”
The former Army chief also evaded questions about his unpublished memoir Four Stars of Destiny after Rahul Gandhi read out passages from it in Lok Sabha on February 2 and claimed PM Modi had abdicated responsibility during 2020 Ladakh crisis.








