From Mohsin Shaikh to Songadh
Indian Muslim, a Decade of Humiliation and Leadership Failure
Syed Zubair Ahmad

When I saw the video clip of Gujarat Police parading nine Muslim youths through the streets of Songadh, Gujarat, with ropes tied around their bodies, after they were accused of throwing stones at the house of a Hindu man who had allegedly made offensive remarks about Moti Masjid on social media.
(No law of the land allows the police to trample upon the dignity of accused persons. If they are guilty, it is for the court to decide and award punishment in accordance with the law. At present, they are merely accused, and the charges against them must be proved in court).
Another picture began to emerge in my mind. I imagined Muslim leaders, instead of the accused youths, being tied with ropes and paraded through the streets of Songadh. These are the people who have degraded the community to such an extent that its members are being humiliated on daily basis simply because they are Muslims.
I imagined Muslim leaders, instead of the accused youths, being tied with ropes and paraded through the streets of Songadh. These are the people who have degraded the community to such an extent that its members are being humiliated simply because they are Muslims.
The so-called leaders of the 200-million-strong Muslim community have become mute spectators since the Modi government came to power. They have remained silent in the face of the inhumane suffering of the Muslim community. They remained silent when Mohsin Shaikh was beaten to death by members of the Hindu Rashtra Sena on June 2, 2014. Shaikh was among the earliest victims of mob lynching after the Modi government came to power.
Over the years, hundreds of Muslims have reportedly been lynched by Hindutva mobs, while more than 10,000 Muslim houses have been demolished. Had these so-called Muslim leaders raised their voices forcefully and collectively against the killing of Mohsin Sheikh, perhaps many subsequent lynchings could have been prevented. Had they launched a determined fight against the injustice of bulldozer demolitions, countless Muslim families might have been spared the trauma of watching their homes reduced to rubble.
Instead, these leaders chose the comfort of silence over the courage of resistance. They failed to mobilise the community, failed to sustain a campaign against these injustices, and failed to hold those responsible accountable. All they seemed capable of doing was issuing routine press statements after every lynching and demolition, as if expressing condemnation on paper were an adequate response to the loss of innocent lives and the destruction of homes.
Their silence when it mattered most has come at a terrible cost. A press statement cannot bring back the dead, rebuild a demolished home, or deter those who believe they can attack Muslims with impunity. Leadership demands courage, sacrifice, and sustained action—not empty words issued after the damage has been done. By repeatedly failing to rise to the occasion, these leaders have squandered opportunities to stand firmly with the community when it needed them most.
Mohsin Sadiq Shaikh, the first victime of Hindutva Terrorists after Modi came to power.
You have lost your dignity. You did not even issue a symbolic statement condemning the arrest of E. Abubacker, who is suffering from multiple life-threatening diseases, including cancer. He is a founding member of the All India Muslim Personal Law Board. Once again, you maintained a criminal silence when Maulana Tauqir Raza Khan was arrested. Perhaps you are waiting for your own turn. This kind of fear is suicidal.
When we pray in our homes, the police arrest us; when we pray in mosques, they demolish them; and when we pray on the streets, the police kick us out. Yet, you have remained silent. You did not even step out of your homes when several mosques were demolished in Delhi. Your silence in the face of such humiliation and injustice is truly disgusting.
I have met some prominent Muslim leaders who believe that “we must have patience, as our resistance will strengthen fascist forces. Today or tomorrow, this government will go.” Is this a strategy, an expression of fear, or a compromise?
Everyone knows that this government, like every other government, will eventually go. A gang of criminals has grabbed power. They are killers and hate-mongers. Your responsibility is to challenge them and confront their divisive politics head-on. But you are afraid. Why?
During the freedom struggle, thousands of ulema fought against the British and sacrificed their lives for the freedom of this country. Why, then, are you afraid of the spies and pensioners of the British? Is this not hypocrisy?
You believe in Almighty Allah. You must also believe that no power in this world can demonise and dictate terms to 200 million Muslims.
Dignity and respect are not merely individual matters. If your community faces humiliation and subjugation on a daily basis, you cannot claim to enjoy respect in the eyes of others. You cannot even escape your identity.
The community has provided you with everything. You enjoy all kinds of luxuries. Wherever you go, you are surrounded by a fleet of expensive cars. Yet, in return, you have made little effort to improve the lives of the people who have supported you. When a fascist government came to power, some of you shifted your allegiance from the BJP to the Congress, while others retreated into their comfort zones, leaving the community high and dry. You maintained a criminal silence in the face of its continuous humiliation and subjugation.
We can endure persecution and humiliation to keep our country integrated and united. But this fascist government is dividing the entire nation in the name of caste and creed. It is now our duty to rise against this regime before it is too late. I believe that Muslim leadership can play a crucial role in saving the country, just as Muslim leaders and ulema made immense sacrifices in the struggle to liberate it from British rule.
I know that if you seriously raise your voice against these injustices, you will face the wrath of tyrannical rulers. But that is part of leadership. You must follow in the footsteps of your forefathers. If you stand firm in the face of oppression, you can emerge victorious.
Come out of the sense of guilt over Partition. Those who wanted Partition left this country. We do not need to prove our patriotism to the spies and pensioners of the British. We demonstrated our patriotism when our ancestors chose this country over Pakistan. We no longer need to offer explanations to anyone.
Those who question our patriotism are the real enemies of India. They are the anti-national elements who seek to divide the country once again in the name of religion. Fight these fascist forces just as our forefathers fought the British. We defeated the British; believe me, we can defeat their spies and ideological successors as well.
The majority of people in this country are peace-loving. Take them into confidence and devise a strategy to unite them against hatred and oppression. Send a clear message to this fascist regime: Enough is enough.
These forces want to rule over the dead bodies of innocent Hindus and Muslims, as they did in Gujarat. They must be confronted. Those who kill innocent people and those who conspire to enable such violence must be challenged. Their politics thrives on fear, division and the suffering of ordinary people.
If you cannot protect your community from humiliation, then stop accepting donations from it. It is ‘haram’ for you to take money from people whose dignity and security you are unwilling to defend. If you have failed in your responsibility, make way for a new generation of leaders. Leave your positions for them. The community deserves leadership that has the courage to stand up for its people, rather than one that merely issues statements after every tragedy.
These leaders, if they cannot learn a lesson from Sonam Wangchuk or the farmers of Punjab, can at least draw inspiration from Irom Sharmila or the women of Shaheen Bagh.









