Muslim councillors booked in Madhya Pradesh after refusing to sing ‘Vande Mataram’
Bhopal: Two Muslim councillors belonging to the Congress party have been booked in Madhya Pradesh’s Indore after they refused to sing India’s patriotic song ‘Vande Mataram’ during a budget session of the municipal corporation, sparking debate over individual rights, religious freedom, and political pressure. It is to be noted that certain words of the song are against the tenets of Islam.
According to Kashmir Media Service, the incident took place on April 8 during the civic body’s budget session, where councillors — Rubina Iqbal Khan and Fauzia Sheikh Aleem — were present when the controversy began.
Police said the case was filed under sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, following complaints from BJP councillors. Additional Deputy Commissioner of Police Ram Sanehi Mishra said, “During the inquiry, it was found that the incident created tension and differences among people. The matter is being investigated further.”
However, the councillors have maintained that their decision was based on religious grounds rather than any intent to create division. During the session, Aleem reportedly questioned whether there was any rule or law that made singing Vande Mataram compulsory. Khan, on her part, said during proceedings that her faith did not permit her to recite the song, adding that she did not intend to hurt sentiments. Meanwhile, BJP members in the House staged protests and raised slogans such as “If you want to live in India, you must say Vande Mataram.”
Police said that both councillors were questioned for two days before the FIR was registered.
The issue has once again brought attention to the historical and legal position of Vande Mataram. Legal experts note the case raises important questions about whether participation in such expressions can be made compulsory, especially when individuals cite faith-based concerns. “There is a clear distinction between respect for national symbols and forced participation,” said a senior advocate, requesting anonymity.
As the investigation continues, the incident has highlighted a wider concern among Indian Muslims about being placed under pressure in matters involving faith and identity.
